Welcome to Coney Island Hot Dogs
Coney Island Hot Dogs, located at 4634 W Main St, Kalamazoo, MI, is a cherished gem that has been serving up delicious, authentic Coney dogs for decades. With a reputation for fast, friendly service and reasonable prices, it’s a favorite among locals. Customers rave about the consistency of the food, particularly the hot dogs and fries, which remain true to their original flavors. The inviting atmosphere reflects a sense of nostalgia, making each visit special. Diners enjoy the hearty portions and the classic menu, ensuring a satisfying experience that feels like home. For a taste of tradition, Coney Island Hot Dogs is a must-try.
Coney Island Hot Dogs: Reviews & Ratings
Nice friendly guy's behind the counter. Normal price on food. Dog's are very good.
I love Coney Island Hot Dogs, and I've loved them for about 40 years! The Coneys are exactly the same as they've always been, as are the fries-they are consistently delicious! The service is fast and friendly, and the prices are reasonable. (And these are REAL Coney Dogs, NOT chili dogs!!)
This place is great they always load the food up, I love eating here and they're baklava is delicious.
First time we were disappointed. Service was very slow. I politely alerted the waitress to my burnt onion rings. She just replied "oh!". It's OK. We love this place and will be back.
A KalamazooGem. Cannot recommend highly enough. Coney Island checks all of my boxes. I only wish that they were open 24/7. Except that would mean that something had changed. And part of why this is one of my happy places is that nothing has changed in the decades I've been going here. (Well, they used to have a great jukebox.) The food hasn't changed, it tastes exactly as marvelous as it did when I was a kid. The menu is almost exactly the same. They haven't added gluten-free buns or tofu dogs, everything is spotless but the booths and the chairs and the trays and the lighting and even the doorway are just as they always were.. I always order the same thing including a Sprecher root beer in the bottle with a frosted mug. And there's nothing hokey about it. Just simple, delicious, food, authentically friendly, fast service. The consistency of everything is highly unusual in my experience. Even the places that I love occasionally have an off day or night where the service is not that great, or they mix up an order or your favorite dish has too much or too little of something. The clientele is varied but the vibe is always wonderful and low-key. It is small, so if you're there at a busy time you may have trouble getting a table or a booth. But people don't tend to linger so things turn over pretty quickly. It's child friendly. You can get orders to go. (I once got on an Amtrak with two Coney dogs and when I unwrapped them people were literally coming over to me and asking me where I got my food.)
Been eating dogs and fries here for years. Finally tried the gyro, was not disappointed! Great place to eat. Some people complain about the price, makes me wonder what grocery store they shop at. Eggs are 4bucks for a dozen these days! Will definitely be back for another gyro!
The people are nice friendly and welcoming it was a great brunch to start my work day.
This place is really good! The decor is clean and the faces are inviting. I love the flavor of the dogs, you can taste the greek influence the second you walk in the door. We will definitely be back when in town.
Location
-
4634 W Main St, Kalamazoo, MI 49006, United States Hotline: +1 269-383-4543
Welcome to Coney Island Hot Dogs, a beloved staple located at 4634 W Main St, Kalamazoo, MI 49006. For over four decades, this local gem has expertly crafted a menu that celebrates the tradition of real Coney dogs—an art that the team here has perfected. As you step inside, you’ll feel the warmth of genuine hospitality from the friendly staff who are known for their fast and attentive service.
One of the standout features of Coney Island Hot Dogs is the authenticity of their offerings. Customers rave about the Coney dogs, declaring them a timeless classic. With each bite, you’ll find a burst of flavors that brings you back to the joy of simpler times. As one loyal patron noted, “the Coneys are exactly the same as they've always been.” This commitment to consistency means you can expect deliciousness on every visit.
Beyond the hot dogs, the restaurant also serves up a variety of sides, including crowd-pleasing fries that have earned their own following. For those with a sweet tooth, the delectable baklava is a surprising and delightful addition that complements the savory dishes well, as highlighted by satisfied customers.
However, every restaurant can have its off days. While some patrons have mentioned slower service or minor mishaps, the overall atmosphere remains uplifting and welcoming. The loyal clientele appreciates that Coney Island Hot Dogs hasn’t lost its charm or quality over the years. As one fan put it, “this is one of my happy places.” With its nostalgic vibe, friendly environment, and mouthwatering food, Coney Island Hot Dogs offers a dining experience that embodies community and comfort.
Whether you’re grabbing a quick bite or enjoying a meal in-house, this establishment promises an array of flavors that satisfy your cravings without breaking the bank. If you haven’t visited yet, now is the perfect time to join the Coney Island family. You might just find your new favorite dish—one that you’ll come back for, time and time again.
For inquiries, you can reach them at +1 269-383-4543. Don’t miss out on the chance to experience this Kalamazoo treasure!